America’s Beloved: The Godfather Review

Introduzione

So, if you read my Substack article, you probably already know my feelings towards The Godfather, along with Italian literature, culture, history, music, food, and women.

A Small Quirk I Do Every Thanksgiving

So, I won’t waste your time. Let’s get down to business and discuss about The Godfather.

Cosa Nostra

The Godfather takes place right after World War II, where Don Vito Corleone, the patriarch of the Corleone Family — and head of one of the Five Families of the east coast, id est, the crime syndicates — holds a party for his daughter’s wedding.

We’re introduced to the main cast, with the men of the family, Sunny, Fredo, Tom Hagen, and the young Michael Corleone, along with others. The story begins when The Don is nearly assassinated by a rival gang after he refused to participate in their business with narcotics.

Now, with the Don out of the game, the Corleone family scrambles and struggles to keep things in order as it looks like everything is about to collapse.

Michael, the youngest, who was never meant to be part of the business slowly but surely gets involved out of duty for his blood. He assures his girlfriend, Kay, that he is different from his family; he’s not like them.

But those words age so poorly as he gradually takes action that makes you question who is Michael Corleone as he takes this dark ride into the world of the mafia.

Il Buono

Like I said in my previous article, one of the reasons why I love this film is because of how Italian it is; it parallels my pride in Mexican culture.

You can read more about it in my article.

But the fact that it’s Italian is the thing that makes it work, especially in the beginning where we have the wedding ceremony. The film allows us to organically participate and explore the world and the people.

It’s like Game of Thrones, where most of the characters unite at a celebration at the beginning only for them to depart to their own misadventures. And believe me, The Godfather has no shortage of misadventures.

And like Game of Thrones, it allows the movie to set up the pieces on the board for us to meet and get to know.

Although Michael is the only dynamic character in the movie, it does not dismiss the other characters who have their quirks, ambitions, and flaws. Even extras like Enzo the Baker remain memorable. Not even the bad guys are forgettable.

All of this was professionally executed with the wide cast it has: Marlon Brando, James Caan, Robert Duvall, Abe Vigoda, Diane Keaton, Talia Shire, and more.

Tom Hagen is my favorite of the cast of characters. It’s probably my favorite role Duvall is in, next to Falling Down. What makes Tom interesting is how he’s not even related to the Corleone family, but remains two hundred plus one percent loyal to Vito Corleone.

After being saved by Vito at a young age, Tom dedicated himself to serving him as a lawyer or Consigliere to the family.

There’s an admiration to be had about his loyalty and wit.

He also acts as a mediator and knows how to stand his ground against other characters who are more physical, like Sunny, which demonstrates some staunchness.

Tom is the tip of the iceberg as there are many other characters to love in this film.

With The Godfather being set in the mid-twentieth century, one aspect that is crucial are the sets and attire.

And this movie DOES NOT disappoint.

I am a sucker for period pieces and The Godfather exceeds expectations.

New York has that classic and classy feel to it, especially in Christmas scenes and it contrasts perfectly with Sicily, where everything looks warm, rugged, yet has that beautiful, ideal, pastoral look to it.

Another element that compliments the Italian feel to the movie is the music. It’s beautiful, traditional and holds a lot of emotion.

Composed by Nino Rota — with a bit of help from Coppola’s father, Carmine Coppola — the music captures those moments.

My favorites come from the hospital scene and when Michael goes to parley with Solozzo. It captures those bleak, dark, tense moments that keeps your eyes glued to the screen.

I can go on and on about how great this film is with all the ingredients it bears. But then comes the question of what is wrong it?

That’s where it gets challenging for me.

Il Cattivo

I will admit: I’m biased toward this film.

This is one of those movies that has left an impression upon me at a young age that I cannot help still love it throughout the years.

But for the sake of integrity, I will try to disclose some flaws that it bears.

One thing I will say that it will not be for everyone as it has a clear audience. It’s fair to say that it’s a “guy film,” but there’s another factor to consider: I don’t think it’s for all generations.

I once sat some younger cousins down who said they were interested in watching The Godfather. But once in the middle of the film, they had their faces to their phones.

As much as it annoyed me, I understood.

The Godfather is not an Avengers film and it certainly is not fast-paced. Or as I like to call it, “Mainstream Slop.”

Courtesy of Screen Rant

It’s a slow burn and requires long-term investment that does reward the audience.

The pacing will be lost on some people.

I think that’s where the whole Family Guy and “It Insists Upon Itself,” attitude comes from.

As Lessons in Meme Culture says, “[These films] are huge classics and in a way, they are so hyped up to be these incredible productions that sometimes they just become insufferable by existing.”

One YouTuber, Rob Ager, a movie critic and analyst, makes the exact point on his video.

Though I don’t agree with all of his opinions, he does have some compelling points that I find difficult to argue. And unlike others who may be trolling, I think he speaks from the heart.

One critique he talks about in the film is the logistics of how events are executed in the movie and leaves a gap logic. Unfortunately, he’s right.

One thing I keep hearing from other critics is how the portrayal of these characters are off: They tend to act like ideal, empathetic, tragic characters rather than sociopathic criminals like the way Scorsese depicts them in his fims.

That is correct. But I would argue that those ideal and fantastic elements of the Cosa Nostra goes with the theme of transience and fatalism in this film (see my previous article to further understand).

Although it is a gangster there’s a sort of poetry that lingers in the air that reaches out at something deeper. That solemn profoundness cannot be attained without its ideal fantastical elements.

In summary, it feels like The Godfather is mostly weak when it is at its strongest.

La Conclusione

I really believe that there’s a rising push-back of The Godfather being overrated. Honestly, that’s fine.

I will say this: if it is overrated, it’s overrated for a reason.

That’s what’s interesting about The Godfather: it’s a movie that doesn’t care. It just shows you for what it is with all honesty and is just rolls with it whether you’re in or out. It’s almost like the movie brings you into these scenes, as boonanaman points out in his analysis, with a welcome.

Due to its slow pacing, this is one of those movies I can have on the background while doing other things and point out what’s going on in the story.

It has the sort of open nature where you can either sit and watch or have it running while you do other things.

Those elements are what make The Godfather America’s beloved film. It has those Italian characteristics, it captures that fatalism that makes the story so compelling, and it has a great cast where everyone is memorable, all set in an era where things were changing into something foreboding in a time of angst.

It’s the perfect mixture of excellent story-telling even if the story itself isn’t perfect.

Because of that, I give The Godfather 9 legendary Italian wines out of ten and my Legendary Seal of Approval!

And that is my review of The Godfather.

As always, what do you think?

You think it’s overrated?

Is nine out of ten too low?

Is it America’s perfect film?

Leave your comments down below and be sure to share with everyone else.

Please be respectful and stay culturally enriched, everyone!

Sources

Boonanaman: Why The Godfather Is A Masterpiece

realBobPhillips: UnPopular Opinion: The Godfather Is Insanely Overrated

Collative Learning: THE GODFATHER is massively overrated. Peter Griffin was right, it does insist on itself. Rob Ager

Lessons in Meme Culture: Seth McFarlane Finally Explains It Insists Upon Itself

Adam, The Dark Legend: A Small Quirk I Do Every Thanksgiving

Leave a Reply

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,